Fall Projects That Add Value to Your Home in Lancaster County

Blog Submitted by Jeremy Ganse, Realtor – RE/MAX SmartHub Realty 

 

In Lancaster County, the National Weather Service puts the median first freeze right around November 1, which makes late fall the last good stretch for outside work. Penn State Extension’s lawn advice, the PA Department of Environmental Protection’s radon guidance, and the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report all point to the same short list. Some of it protects what your house is already worth from a winter of ice, leaves, and frozen pipes. Some of it adds value a buyer will pay for. Here’s how we’d spend a fall weekend, and a fall budget, on a Lancaster County house.

What should you do in the yard before winter? 

Start with the leaves, and don’t bag all of them. A Penn State Extension Master Gardener puts it simply: a lawn mower is the only tool you need. Mow over the leaves to shred them, and a layer up to about half an inch is good for the lawn. If they’re piled too thick to shred, rake some off first.

Pickup rules change from town to town. The City of Lancaster takes leaves only in paper yard waste bags, on your trash day during its scheduled yard waste weeks. East Hempfield Township wants them loose at the curb, with crews making passes from mid-October to mid-December. Check your township’s page before you bag anything.

Time the last fertilizer with the last mow. Penn State recommends the late-fallapplication around the season’s final mowing, before the soil freezes, and says not to fertilize between December 15 and March 1.
Bare patches can wait. Penn State doesn’t suggest seeding later than mid-October in most of Pennsylvania, so mark those spots for late summer.

Then look up. Penn State suggests watering trees and shrubs younger than five years into late fall, before the ground freezes. Note dead branches over the roof or driveway, too. Ice and snow break weak limbs, and Penn State calls winter tree pruning season because bare branches let you see the tree’s structure. If you can’t reach a branch from the ground, call an arborist.

How do you keep water out of the house this winter? 

Clean the gutters once most of the leaves are down, then check where the downspouts empty. The University of Minnesota Extension says extensions should carry water at least 4 feet beyond the wall, and that a downspout without an extender or splash block is worse than no downspout at all.

Dry leaves clogging a roof gutter below asphalt shingles 

Shut down the outdoor faucets before a hard freeze. The Red Cross routine: drain and store the hoses, close the inside valve that feeds each outdoor spigot, then open the spigot outside and leave it open so leftover water has room to expand.

Ice dams usually start with heat leaking into the attic. It melts snow on the roof; the melt refreezes at the colder edge, and water backs up under the shingles. Sealing those leaks pays twice. The U.S. Department of Energy estimates that sealing uncontrolled air leaks can save 10% to 20% on heating and cooling bills, and PPL Electric Utilities offers rebates on air sealing and insulation for eligible homes.

Book the chimney and furnace checks, too. The National Fire Protection Association’s chimney standard, NFPA 211, calls for chimneys, fireplaces, and vents to be inspected at least once a year, and ENERGY STAR puts the heating check in the fall.

Are new windows worth it? 

If your windows are single-pane, fogged between the panes, or soft at the sill, yes. ENERGY STAR estimates that replacing single-pane windows with certified ones lowers household energy bills by an average of up to 13% nationwide.

Installer fitting a new window frame into an opening 

Be clear-eyed about resale, though. In the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report, vinyl replacement windows in York, the closest market to Lancaster that the report tracks, recouped about 76% of their cost. New windows are a comfort and energy project. At resale, they don’t pay for themselves.

Two more things. The federal tax credit for energy-efficient windows and doors ended for anything installed after December 31, 2025, so a 2026 install gets no federal credit. And if your windows are decent double-pane units, start with air sealing and attic insulation instead.

Which upgrades pay you back when you sell?

The front of the house. In the report’s York numbers, a steel entry door replacement recouped about 182% of its cost and a new garage door about 119%. Nationally, the steel entry door came in at 216% and the garage door at 268%. The resale values are estimates from more than 6,000 Realtors, so use them to plan, not as a promise for your address. Few projects in the report return more than they cost. These two do in every Pennsylvania city where the report prices them.

Brick house with a two-car garage and a front entry door on a sunny fall day

Why is fall the time to test for radon? 

Your house is about to be shut tight for the season, and that’s when a test counts. The PA DEP says the best time to test is during the colder months, when homes are closed.

Radon matters more here than in most places. Lancaster County sits in Zone 1, the highest of the EPA’s three radon zones, and DEP reports that about 40% of Pennsylvania homes tested come in above the EPA action level of 4 picocuries per liter. The EPA calls radon the number one cause of lung cancer among nonsmokers.

DEP puts a home test kit at about $20 to $30 at a hardware or home improvement store, and a short-term test sits in your house for two to seven days. If a follow-up test still reads 4 or higher, hire a DEP-certified mitigator. DEP keeps a list by county.

There’s a selling angle, too. Pennsylvania’s seller disclosure form asks sellers what they know about radon on the property. A recent test result, or a working system with a passing retest, is one less thing for a buyer to negotiate.

What can wait until spring? 

Three fall-sounding jobs belong on next year’s list. Grass seed goes down in late summer. Penn State’s rule for fall planting is at least six weeks before the first frost, so new trees and shrubs move to spring or next September. And most driveway sealers want 50 to 55 degrees and rising, so that job waits for warm weather.

Local help we trust 

  • Lawn and tree questions: the Penn State Extension Master Gardener is free for Lancaster County gardeners. Call 717-394-6851 or email a photo to lancastermg@psu.edu.
  • Seed, fertilizer, and supplies: Stauffers of Kissel Hill in Lititz and Rohrerstown, Esbenshade’s in Lititz, family-owned since 1960, and Rohrer Seeds on Old Philadelphia Pike, selling seed since 1919. 
  • Old doors, cabinets, and double-pane windows: the Lancaster Lebanon Habitat for Humanity ReStore at 1061 Manheim Pike takes them as donations (no single-pane windows).
  • Rebates: PPL Electric Utilities for air sealing, insulation and smart thermostats, and UGI for high-efficiency gas furnaces.
  • Window installers, gutter crews and arborists: tell us what you’re planning and we’ll point you to local pros we’ve seen do good work.

Planning to sell in the spring? A fall walk-through tells you which of these projects matter for your house and which can wait. We’ll spend ten minutes looking at it the way a buyer will and hand you a short list, in order. Contact the Jeremy Ganse Team.