Bagnall Shaw Insurance

401 W. Orange Street
Lancaster, PA 17603
717-431-8383

Auto Home Business Life Travel

Bagnall Shaw Insurance is Downtown Lancaster’s #1 Independent Insurance Broker for home, auto, commercial, and life insurance needs! Serving all of Pennsylvania since 2008! Over 70 National Carriers Quoted for FREE in 20 minutes or less!! NEVER any Agency Fees or Broker Fees! Guaranteed Lowest Rates! “We Shop…You Save!”

Why Choose Bagnall Shaw Insurance?

We can quote you up to 70 companies at once for FREE in 20 minutes or less!
Our average new customer Saves Over 25% by shopping insurance with us!
SAVE TIME! One quick visit gets you all available quotes at once to compare.
SAVE MONEY! If rates go up you are never “stuck” with your carrier.
PRICE GUARANTEE! Our quotes are the same prices as you calling each carrier.
ALWAYS FREE GUARANTEE! Never any charges to you for our insurance services.
Never any “Agency Fees” or “Broker Fees” like some greedy competitors do!
Speak to an experienced insurance advisor every time you call.
Always get personalized coverage recommendations from your agent.
Our loyalty is only to YOU and YOUR best interests, and never just one insurance carrier like Erie, State Farm, Allstate, Farmers and Geico Agents are required to do at your expense!!
EXCLUSIVE CARRIER MULTIPLE DISCOUNTS AVAILABLE! These include Exclusive Competition Price-Match Offers, AAA, Home Owner, Good Student, Safe Driver, Safe Home, Multi-Policy, Automatic Payment, & Claims-Free Cashback
Need help with a claim? We are always here to assist you!

Since 2008, Bagnall Shaw Insurance’s goal has been to guarantee that our local Lancaster & statewide Pennsylvania repeat clients have the right coverage at the absolute lowest price anywhere. We only partner with the most highly respected, consumer-friendly carriers in our industry. Imagine having a broker that ignores commissions and commits their focus to finding you the best insurance coverage that you can afford.

Using our exclusive, modern technology; We offer LIVE, REAL-TIME FREE QUOTES from up to 70 A and A+ Rated Insurance Carriers at once for you to compare and shop for free with absolutely no obligation!

Our exclusive 15 Minute Super Saver Multi-Quote saves the average new client 30% off their home and auto premium when written together!

90% of our clients return year after year because our service and prices are unbeatable!

It’s time for you to discover the “Bagnall Shaw Difference” and SAVE BIG with us too!!

DOWNTOWN LANCASTER’S LARGEST, INDEPENDENT INSURANCE AGENCY.
FASTEST GROWING INSURANCE BROKERAGE SINCE 2008!